Yesterday morning, that shower was used for the first time in at least a year. The kids still take baths. I heard a drip, drip, drip in the kitchen and was surprised to see it coming from the ceiling. Grrrrr. I made a quick call to Kennedy Plumbing to have them come out to check to see if the first guy screwed up. It turned out that after an hour of trying to diagnose the problem, he finally found it. When the tub faucet runs, it doesn't leak, but when the shower starts, it drips lots. He took the faucet assembly apart to find a disintegrated O-ring. Ooops. So the first guy did right, and the second guy did too. The only problem is that now, enough water had leaked into our ceiling that I really did have to fix it. The plumber was kind enough to saw out a very rough hole to help him diagnose the problem. Now I get to fix it. Ho hum. I really hate dry-wall work. Maybe it will get done before next year. :)

Consider a pro
The drywall part is pretty easy really, but the texture matching, not so much. You're likely to always see it. especially if you do it yourself or watch the guy who does very closely. I think in this case, unless you really want to learn how to do a small knockdown brocade texture (I'll be happy to help if you do), I'd consider hiring a professional. Folks are looking for work right now, so if you look around you can probably get a decent deal from a reputable drywall/plaster guy.
--dvhart
Drywall
Whenever I've had to do drywall work, it was in the garage. I think it still needs to be painted, but at least it won't have to be textured.
Have fun!